AI vs Travel Agent: Which is Best for Trip Planning?

Remember when planning a trip meant visiting the library or bookstore for a bunch of travel guides or making an appointment with a travel agent? Today, most of us start our travel planning with a Google search and then spend hours reading online reviews. 

The internet is a far cry from that stack of books and notepads on the kitchen table, and the use of travel agents dropped off some time ago.

However, there are new players in the trip-planning game these days: artificial intelligence (AI) and travel agents are back!

AI tools promise to make trip planning more effortless than ever; at the same time, travel agents have modernized their services, offering expertise and support that goes far beyond what we have time to find online by ourselves.

In this article, we’ll learn when to use AI tools and when to call a travel agent. Let’s get started!

Today’s Travel Planning Landscape

Here’s what you need to know about today’s travel planning options.

AI Travel Tools

• Google’s AI can now suggest entire itineraries based on your interests
• ChatGPT can create custom travel plans and packing lists (if you know how to use it)
• Apps like Hopper use AI to predict the best time to book flights
• Many hotel websites use AI chatbots for customer service (for better or worse)

Modern Travel Agents

• Today’s agents work remotely and communicate by email or phone
• They have access to special deals not available to the public
• Many specialize in specific types of travel (cruises, luxury, adventure)
• They provide emergency support during your trip – a real person to call if things go wrong

The best news is that you don’t have to pick just one approach. Many travelers now use both AI tools and travel agents, depending on the type of trip they want to take and how much time they have to plan.

AI tools work best for these situations

If you’ve spent any time experimenting with AI tools like ChatGPT or Google’s Gemini, you know they can be incredibly helpful – once you get the hang of them. Just like learning to use a smartphone, there’s a learning curve. If you’re comfortable with the back-and-forth nature of having a conversation with AI, it can become your first stop for many travel planning tasks. Assuming you’re familiar with how to use AI tools, here’s when to let AI technology take the lead: For Simple, Direct TripsPlanning trips you’ve made before but need updatingBooking familiar routes (like visiting family)Finding hotels in cities you know wellCreating daily itineraries in well-traveled destinationsWhen You Need Quick Fact-CheckingConfirming current visa requirementsLooking up travel advisoriesChecking weather patternsVerifying attraction hours and pricesFor Budget ResearchComparing flight prices across multiple datesFinding deals on hotel roomsGetting estimates for daily expensesTracking price changes over timeSafety Tip: While AI tools are helpful, always double-check critical information (like visa requirements or travel advisories) on official websites. AI can sometimes work with outdated information, which could affect your safety. Money-Saving Tip: Use AI tools for initial research, then check prices directly on airline and hotel websites. Sometimes booking directly can save you money and give you more flexibility if plans change. Reminder: AI tools work best when you ask specific questions. For example, instead of “Where should I go in Spain?” try “What are the safest areas in Madrid for senior travelers within walking distance of the Prado Museum?” Or try this: “I’m a 55-year-old traveler looking for five-star hotels in Lake Como, Italy, during July. Safety and accessibility are the top priority. I’d also like to have a direct view of the lake and a balcony. What do you suggest?” Here’s a sample of the result you’ll get:

Travel Agents work best in these situations

Travel agents have had a rough time of it – their jobs nearly disappeared with the internet, but with the complexity of travel these days, they’re back and valued again.

Here’s when using a travel agent makes good sense:

For complex or higher-risk trips

• Multi-city vacations across a wide region or multiple countries
• Off-the-beaten-path destinations
• Countries where you don’t speak the language
• Areas with known travel risks
• Longer cruise trips with multiple stops and excursions
• Trips where you want flexibility in your return date

If you have special requirements

• Medical conditions that need accommodation
• Dietary restrictions that need advance planning
• Mobility issues that require special arrangements
• Specific room requirements (like ground floor access)

If you want absolute peace of mind — travel agents are stars when it comes to:

• Someone to call 24/7 if problems arise (some travel insurance plans have this too)
• Help with rebooking if flights are canceled
• Assistance during weather emergencies
• Support with lost passport situations

Making a hybrid approach work for you

The smartest travelers know that it’s not about choosing one over the other, but instead about using both options wisely. Here’s a practical way to combine trip-planning options:1. Start with some AI research of your own. Use the AI tool of your choice to:

• Explore destinations and create initial itineraries
• Generate a list of safety concerns
• Draft a list of questions to ask the travel agent or research further

2. Then, consult a travel agent for:

• Their advice to improve your draft trip plan
• Booking complex parts of your trip
• Adding in safety nets like flexible cancellation or changing return dates

Finally, keep your AI tool handy on your phone as a backup for quick fact-checking while on your trip, making last-minute restaurant recommendations, translating signs or menus, and keeping an eye on the local weather.

It can help to thin of AI as your research assistant and your travel agent as the safety expert. Using both to create a travel plan gives you both independence and security. 

This combined approach helps you stay in control of your travel planning while having professional support when you need it most.

Related Topics

• How to plan a multi-generational trip
• Hidden fees and fake numbers – the latest car rental scams
• Upcoming changes for US Travelers to Europe